Fair Fighting Rules

Fighting Rules
Relational conflict often involves some form of fighting. It may look like heated disagreements that end nowhere, trigger reactive words that magnify emotional wounds, and uncontained strong emotions that can result in unhealthy coping or impulsive behaviors one later regrets.

While fighting is often viewed as a bad thing, the avoidance of conflict is not so healthy either. The key is to engage in fair fighting and utilize fair fighting rules. This helps provide a framework that helps serve as a model of engagement so that fighting is done in a way that is fair, feels safe, and is productive for all involved.

While you can take fair fighting rules and implement them in your own relationships, utilizing these with the support of a trained family or couples’ therapist is most effective. Here are six reasons why:

Therapy provides a structured safe space to fight fairly.

How many times have you wanted to address something with a partner only to hear things like “Now is not the time or place” or “Let’s not do this in front of [our kids/ our friends]”. Perhaps you set the matter aside only to completely avoid addressing it altogether. Regularly scheduled therapy sessions give you a set date/ time to address topics without avoidance.

Individuals are provided with support to process thoughts and feelings and identify the core conflicts.

Therapists can help couples and their partner(s) understand what they are experiencing and get beneath the surface emotion to identify core fears and vulnerabilities that show up in relationships. Often the little things that trigger strong emotions are a cumulative build-up.

Therapy helps contain strong emotions and set boundaries.

To have productive conflict, there need to be some ground rules in place. Common fair fighting rules include no yelling, taking turns while speaking, using respectful language, and using a time-out if needed.

Therapists are skilled to work with the four horsemen that show up: criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling. By identifying these patterns, your therapist can help learn constructive ways to express anger and restore the health of unhelpful patterns that ultimately end many relationships.

Therapists help enforce good boundaries.

Establishing fair fighting rules and boundaries is one thing, but it may take professional support to help enforce these. Showing up drunk or high not going to lead to productive conflict. Derailing from established ground rules to where the space is feeling emotionally or physically unsafe is not conducive to good work. Your therapist may utilize the use of breaks to help each person calm down and then circle back with a plan to work with triggers. In some cases (e.g., when intimate partner violence is currently present), couples therapy may not be discontinued, and additional resources along with individual therapy may be recommended.

Therapists can help recognize and celebrate the wins.

In fair fighting, the focus is on a win for the relationship vs. winning the argument. It is important to recognize and celebrate these! The outcome could be painful but ultimately there is a win for the relationship when each person can have space to express where they feel heard and can come to a mutual understanding or compromise that resolves the presenting concern.

Written By: Charlotte Johnson, MA, LPCC

Understanding CARE Coordination

Understanding CARE Coordination

Care coordination is an important aspect of your treatment; understanding this service can help ensure you receive the best care possible.
gaining independence

Gaining Independence and Finding Yourself After Being in an Unhealthy Relationship

It can be hard to adjust to a new norm after relationships end. It can also be tough to cope with the thoughts and feelings that come up after no longer being in a relationship you didn’t think would ever end.
Death Anxiety (Thanatophobia)

Death Anxiety (Thanatophobia)

While fear of death is a common existential fear, some people have intense fears of themselves or a loved one dying. An extreme fear of death or the dying process, known as thanatophobia is considered as a specific fear, or phobia that is under the broader category of anxiety disorders.
Understanding Fear: Questions to Ask Yourself

Understanding Fear: Questions to Ask Yourself

If you are experiencing significant discomfort or find that there are things that you want to do, but are unable to do because of fear, then talking with a mental health specialist is recommended. Fear that becomes persistent can take a toll on both your physical and mental health, so it is important to take preventative measures.
Sexual Violence Prevention

Sexual Violence Prevention

What (or who) do you turn to amid suffering? How about when faced with situations that seem beyond your own control? As strong as you are, you may feel weak or helpless. Adverse childhood experiences, community violence, and sexual violence are just a few of many serious public health problems that impact communities.
The Importance of Learning about Trauma (Psychoeducation) for All Ages

The Importance of Learning about Trauma (Psychoeducation) for All Ages

Psychoeducation can be provided in many forms including printed and web-based materials such as facts sheets, psychoeducational videos, books, and conversations with professionals in the field. Hearing stories from those who have experienced similar events can also be helpful. All these methods help normalize the reactions to traumatic events and can reduce feelings of guilt and shame through sharing of information and common experiences.
Learning How to Love Yourself & Living with Bipolar Disorder

Learning How to Love Yourself & Living with Bipolar Disorder

Did you know that seeking help for your mental health is an act of self-love? While bipolar can significantly impair functioning, many individuals are living with bipolar disorder and thriving!
3 LGBTQ Hotlines You Need To Know

3 LGBTQ Hotlines You Need to Know

Having access to resources to help deescalate emotional distress and manage (or prevent) states of crisis can help empower individuals to take control over their mental health and well-being.
Providing Affirmative Mental Healthcare: 6 Things You Should Know blog cover photo rainbow sky with two hands reaching out

Providing Affirmative Mental Healthcare: 6 Things You Should Know

Healthcare professionals play a necessary role in supporting the LBGTQ+ community, by providing affirmative relationships that don’t perpetuate attitudes of ignorance or discrimination.
3 ways to help children with school anxiety blog cover image school auditorium lecture hall

3 Ways to Help Children with School Anxiety & Somatic Complaints

School refusal and reluctance to go to school due to frequent complaints of aches and pain can be a challenging topic for parents and caregivers to manage.
supporting your gut graphic

Supporting Your Gut “the Second Brain”

If you ever had a “gut feeling” experienced as intuition, “butterflies” feelings of dread, disgust, anticipatory anxiety, or an instinctive urge to respond with action, these are all examples of your brain communicating with your gut.
bullying prevention

Bullying Prevention: The Role of Parents, School Staff, and Adults in the Community

Bullying is among the top concerns for parents, especially related to worries about their child struggling with anxiety, depression, and the fear of suicide.
Talking about women's rights

Talking about Women’s Roles & Rights (Human Rights) in Therapy

It is important to consider the impact of gender and other aspects of identity when exploring discrimination and privilege related to human rights and the emotional, psychological, and social implications on one’s mental health.
Body Appreciation / Body Neutrality

Body Appreciation / Body Neutrality

Reducing body dissatisfaction is an important topic. Oftentimes, one’s self-esteem is tied to physical appearance, with emphasis on body shape and size. How you feel about your body is going to directly impact your thoughts and the choices you make.
Coping with Stress and the Impacts on Eating

Coping with Stress and the Impacts on Eating

We all have our go-to strategies for coping with stress, and some strategies are healthier than others. I’d like to explore each area in detail, and share how certain strategies impact our eating and provide resources for hope.
Consent Before Sexual Activity: 6 Things You Need to Know

Consent Before Sexual Activity: 6 Things You Need to Know

Consent is an agreement of sexual activity, with clear boundaries discussed before, during, and after engaging in sexual behaviors.
Sexual Health Without Stigma or Shame

Sexual Health Without Stigma or Shame

Sexual health is one of many areas that your therapist will ask about in either your first or second session. There are so many areas related to sexual health that come up in therapy, so rest assured that it is OK to talk about it without sitgma or shame.
Self-Esteem Check In

Self-Esteem Check In

Self-esteem is a topic that comes up a lot in therapy, especially around dates that may trigger social comparison and loneliness.Self-esteem is a topic that comes up a lot in therapy, especially around dates that may trigger social comparison and loneliness.
Stress Could Be Breaking Your Heart

Stress Could Be Breaking Your Heart

Our bodies are designed to respond to stress, but chronic and long-term stress can take its toll on physical and mental health.
Finding a Mental Health Therapist

Finding a Mental Health Therapist

For those trying to find a therapist, it is frustrating when you call around, only to find yourself put on a waitlist, with these often being 3-months or longer. Problems don’t wait, and you shouldn’t have to wait either.
How to find inspiration to make positive changes, text over an image of hands making pottery on a pottery wheel

How to Find Inspiration to Make Positive Changes

If you are aware that some things need to change and are ready to do something about it but need some inspiration to get started, keep reading. I’ll be sharing ideas that others have found helpful to inspire motivation to act. These profoundly simple ideas can make a huge difference!
foggy window graphic

5 Ways CARE is Reducing Barriers to Mental Health Treatment

Did you know that in 2022, CARE Counseling supported over 15,000 individuals and families and in 2023 therapists held 175,196 appointments? That is a lot of people helped!
Martin Luther King Jr. graphic

Civil Rights Movement: Remembering MLK and our Nation’s History

Dr. Martin Luther King’s presence is found within our communities, throughout the United States, worldwide. Look around you and you will likely see places memorialized by Dr. King.